1.Henry A.Kissinger,Diplomacy(New York:Simon & Schuster,1994),pp 23-24. ↩
2.H.D.S.Greenway’s phrase,Boston Globe,3 December 1992,p.19. ↩
3.Vaclav Havel,“The New Measure of Man,” New York Times,8 July 1994,p.A27;Jacques Delors,“Questions Concerning European Security,”Address,International Institute for Strategic Studies,Brussels,10 September 1993,p.2. ↩
4.Thomas S.Kuhn,The Structure of Scientific Revolutions,(Chicago:University of Chicago Press,1962),pp.17-18. ↩
5.John Lewis Gaddis,“Toward the Post-Cold War World.”Foreign Affairs,70 (Spring 1991),101;Judith Goldstein and RobertO.Keohane,“Ideas and Foreign Policy:An Analytical Framework,”in Goldstein and Keohane,eds.,Ideas and Foreign Policy:Beliefs,Institutions,and Political Change (Ithaca:Cornell University Press,1993),pp.8-17. ↩
6.Francis Fukuyama,“The End of History,”The National Interest,16(Summer 1989),4,18. ↩
7.“Address to the Congress Reporting on the Yalta Conference,”1 March 1945,in Samuel I.Rosenman,ed.,Public Papers and Addresses of Franklin D.Roosevelt (New York:Russell and Russell,1969),XIII,586. ↩
8.See Max Singer and Aaron Wildavsky,The Real World Order:Zones of Peace,Zones of Turmoil (Chatham,NJ:Chatham House,1993);Robert o.Keohane and Joseph S.Nye,“Introduction:The End of the Cold War in Europe,”in Keohane,Nye,and Stanley Hoffmann,eds.,After the Cold War:International Institutions and State Strategies in Europe,1989-1991 (Cambridge:Harvard University Press,1993),p.6;and James M.Goldgeier and Michael McFaul,“A Tale of Two Worlds:Core and Periphery in the Post-Cold War Era,”International Organization,46(Spring 1992),467-491. ↩
9.See F.S.C.Northrop,The Meeting of East and West:An Inquiry Concerning World Understanding (New York:Macmillan,1946). ↩
10.Edward W.Said,Orientalism (New York:Pantheon Books,1978),pp.43-44. ↩
11.See Kenneth N.Waltz,“The Emerging Structure of International Politics,”International Security,18 (Fall 1993),44-79;John J.Mearsheimer,“Back to the Future:Instability in Europe after the Cold War,”International Security,15 (Summer 1990),5-56. ↩
12.Stephen D.Krasner questions the importance of Westphalia as a dividing point.See his“Westphalia and All That,”in Goldstein and Keohane,eds.,Ideas and Foreign Policy ,pp.235-264. ↩
13.Zbignew Brzezinski,Out of Control:Global Turmoil on the Eve of the Twenty-first Century (New York:Scribner,1993);Daniel Patrick Moynihan,Pandaemonium:Ethnicity in International Politics (Oxford:Oxford University Press,1993);see also Robert Kaplan,“The Coming Anarchy,”Atlantic Monthly,273 (Feb.1994),44-76. ↩
14.See New York Times,7 February 1993,pp.1,14;and Cabriel Schoenfeld,“Outer Limits,”Post-Soviet Prospects,17 (Jan.1993),3,citing figures from the Russian Ministry of Defense. ↩
15.See Gaddis,“Toward the Post-Cold War World”;Benjamin R.Barber,“Jihad vs.McWorld,”Atlantic Monthly,269 (March 1992),53-63,and Jihad vs.McWorld (New York:Times Books,1995);Hans Mark,“After Victory in the Cold War:The Global Village or Tribal Warfare,”in J.J.Lee and Walter Korter,eds.,Europe in Transition:Political,Economic,and Security Prospects for the 1990s (LBJ School of Public Affairs,University of Texas at Austin,March 1990),pp.19-27. ↩
16.John J.Mearsheimer,“The Case for a Nuclear Deterrent,”Foreign Affairs,72 (Summer 1993),54. ↩
17.Lester B.Pearson,Democracy in World Politics (Princeton:Princeton University Press,1955),pp.82-83. ↩
18.Quite independently Johan Galtung developed an analysis that closely parallels mine on the salience to world politics of the seven or eight major civilizations and their core states.See his“The Emerging Conflict Formations,”in Katharine and Majid Tehranian,eds.,Restructuring for World Peace:On the Threshold of the Twenty-First Century (Cresskill NJ:Hampton Press,1992),pp.23-24.Galtung sees seven regional-cultural groupings emerging dominated by hegemons:the United States,European Community,Japan,China,Russia,India,and an“Islamic core.”Other authors who in the early 1990s advanced similar arguments concerning civilizations include:Michael Lind,“American as an Ordinary Country,”American Enterprise,1 (Sept./Oct.1990),19-23;Barry Buzan,New Patterns of Global Security in the Twenty-first Century,“ International Affairs,67 (1991),441,448-449;Robert Gilpin,”The Cycle of Great Powers:Has It Finally Been Broken?“(Princeton University ,unpublihed paper,19 May 1993),pp.6ff.;William S.Lind,”North-South Relations:Returning to a World of Cultures in Conflict,-Current World Leaders,35 (Dec.1992),1073-1080,and“Defending Western Culture,”Foreign Policy,84 (Fall 1994),40-50;“Looking Back from 2992:A World History,chap.13:The Disastrous 21st Century,” Economist,26 December 1992-8 January 1993,pp.17-19;“The New World Order:Back to the Future,” Economist,8 January 1994,pp.21-23;“A Survey of Defence and the Democracies,”Economist,1 September 1990;Zsolt Rostovanyi,“Clash of Civilizations and Cultures:”Unity and Disunity of World Order,-(unpublished paper,29 March 1993);Michael Vlahos,“Culture and Foreign Policy,”Foreign policy,82 (Spring 1991),59-78;Donald J.Puchala,“The History of the Future of International Relations,”Ethics and International Affairs,8 (1994),177-202;Mahdi Elmandjra,“Cultural Diversity:Key to Survival in the Future,” (Paper presented to First Mexican Congress on Future Studies,Mexico City,September 1994).In 1991 Elmandjra published in Arabic a book which appeared in French the following year entitled Premiere Guerre Civilisationnelle (Casablanca:Ed.Toubkal,1982,1994). ↩
19.Fernand Braudel,On History (Chicago:University of Chicago Press,1980),pp.210-211. ↩